Opens in a new tab

How to Pick the Right Keywords for SEO in 2026 (After AI Overviews Compressed Half of Them)

Choosing the right keywords is essential if you want to be successful with your organic growth and SEO strategy.  

In this article, we’re going to be exploring how to choose the right keywords for SEO. We’ll also be diving into a number of little-known strategies you can use to identify high-traffic AND high-profitability keywords for your business.

These keywords can then be used to create new website content or blog content that will help you boost your organic rankings in search engines like Google.

It’s worth saying here that before starting an SEO campaign, you should make sure you have solid foundations in place. This includes things like optimising you title-tags and meta-descriptions. I got into this in more detail in our blog how to identify you SEO quick-wins.

Firstly, we need to understand and get clear on the different types of keywords and search intent:

Understanding Keyword Types

So the first step to picking the right keywords for SEO is to understand the different types of keywords.

Keywords are typically broken down into 3 main categories:

  • Short-tail keywords (also known as head, broad, or generic keywords)
  • Mid-tail keywords
  • Long-tail keywords

As you’ll see from the image below by SEMRush; the short-tail keywords have high search volume but are very broad in nature:

For that reason, they tend to have a much lower conversion rate because it’s a very vague search term.

We don’t know if the person searching “tomato plant” is looking for tips on caring for tomato plants, buying a tomato plant, or maybe they even just want to find out what a tomato plant is!

Short-tail keywords will also typically be much harder to rank for as they are highly competitive with tonnes of search results.

However, on the opposite end of the spectrum, high-tail keywords (often more of a phrase than a word) usually convert more of that traffic into leads because there is more intent behind the search.

For example, in the image above, we know this person is having an issue with their tomato plants turning yellow so we can address their concerns and offer them a relevent answer/solution.

With this in mind, you’ll want to make sure you’re finding long-tail keywords to create your content around to begin with.

Over time and as your domain/page authority grows, you’ll start naturally ranking for more short tail keywords too!

Understanding Search Intent

The next thing we need to understand is search intent. This is one of Google’s primary ranking factors and understanding it is essential for any successful SEO Campaign.

The search intent behind keywords can again be broken down into 3 buckets:

  • Navigational
  • Informational
  • Transactional

Whether you’re creating a “services” page on your website or a “how to” blog, it’s important to be mindful of the intent behind that search.

You’ll want to be sure that the content on the page is delivering upon the intent of that specific search.

Understanding Latent Semantic Indexing (LSI) Keywords

In a nutshell, LSI keywords are search terms related to the main keyword you are targeting.

They help to support your content and add more context to it. This make’s it easier for both visitors and search engines to know what your content is about.

For example, as you’ll see in the image below, LSI tools and LSI graph could be considered related terms to somebody searching for Latent Semantic Indexing.

With this in mind, when you’re writing your content, you’ll want to think about a number of sub categories or topics that could potentially fall under the main topic.

This not only helps to bring more value to the reader but will also help Google understand the context and rank your page accordingly.

Auditing Your Current Organic Keyword Rankings

Now that we’re clear on how keywords work and the different types to be aware of; The first thing to do is to audit your current keyword rankings.

The reason for this is to help prioritise the keywords you’re targeting.

For example, we often speak to clients who spend insane amounts of time and money trying to rank for highly competitive keywords which they are currently not even ranking for.

However, they often have some great keywords (with high commercial intent) which they are already ranking for but are maybe at the bottom of page 1 or the top of page 2.

This is the kind of low-hanging fruit we want to start with on an SEO campaign because even the smallest increase in position on a page 1 and 2 ranking can make a significant increase to your traffic.

On the other hand, let’s say you had a keyword you’re currently ranked 99 for…

Even if you were to jump 50 positions, you would only see marginal (if any) increase in traffic!

Ubersuggest is a great free tool to check your current keywords; simply type in your website and head down to SEO Keywords to view your current keywords and their current position in the SERP (Search Engine Results Page)

How To Choose The Right Keywords For Your Blog/Website Content

Once you’ve checked your current keyword positions, you’ll want to work out where you’re high-priority keywords might be.

Don’t worry if you’re not ranking for any keywords of you don’t have any low-hanging fruit here.

I’ll be showing you how to find high opportunity keywords.

There’re two great strategies for doing keyword research and getting some initial keyword ideas.

First is using Google’s Autosuggest feature which gives you a list of suggestions other people have searched for when you begin typing a search into Google.

Google Autosuggest

The next is a little known technique that allows you to get additional ideas for any given topic.

Simply add an Asterix before any short-tail keyword and Google will give you a list of additional long-tail phrases people search for relating to that keyword as seen in the example below:

Google Related Searches

Another way to get keyword ideas is to just scroll to the bottom of the search engine results page and Google will give you a list of related searches.

Now that you’ve got a list of ideas for long-tail keywords, you’ll want to prioritise these by the amount of search volume and the difficulty to rank for that given keyword.

Here’s a few tools to help you with that.

Best Keyword Research Tools

Keywords Everywhere is a fantastic chrome extension that allows you to quickly and easily view the average monthly search volume for keywords in any search engine (including YouTube)

You’ll also see a rating for competition – this gives you an indication of how difficult that keyword would be to rank for.

When it comes to prioritising your SEO keyword strategy, you’ll want to prioritise the keywords with a decent search volume but low competition.

Whilst it might be alluring, keywords with 10,000+ monthly searches will be highly competitive and difficult to rank for.

So when you’re starting out, I’d recommend looking for keywords with between 10 to 1,000 searches per month and a low competition score.

You can then prioritise these further looking for the highest search volume and lowest competition keywords. Next you’ll want to start creating content targeting those high-priority keywords.

Once you’ve started ranking for a few of these keywords, you’ll start naturally start to pick up additional keyword rankings and can move onto more competitive keywords.

And there you have it! That’s how to pick the RIGHT keywords for your SEO strategy to ensure stable and solid growth over time.

If you’d like any additional advice on your SEO strategy be sure to book your FREE website & marketing audit today!

Book your FREE digital review today and we’ll record you a 10 minute video looking at your current SEO & keyword strategy and suggest some ways you could significantly increase your traffic, leads and sales!

The honest update

This guide originally walked through standard keyword research: find queries with decent volume, low competition, ideally commercial intent. The fundamentals still apply. But the playbook needs serious updating because Google’s AI Overviews now compress click-through rates by 30-60% on a huge share of informational queries. Ranking #1 for some keywords in 2026 produces fewer clicks than ranking #5 did in 2018.

So here’s the 2026 framework for picking keywords actually worth ranking for.

The three keyword categories that matter in 2026

Don’t think about keywords as one homogeneous category. Three distinct buckets:

Category 1: Commercial intent (still high-value)

These are the keywords where someone is researching a purchase decision. “Best CRM for B2B SaaS,” “Shopify alternatives,” “how to choose [vendor type].”

Google still serves clickable results for these because AI Overviews struggle to recommend specific products without seeming biased. CTR holds up. ROI on ranking is still strong.

Prioritise these.

Category 2: Pure informational (compressed by AI Overviews)

“What is bounce rate,” “how does attribution work,” “what is GA4.” The questions where Google’s AI Overview can answer in 100 words and most users don’t click through.

For these, the play has changed. Don’t optimise primarily for traffic. Optimise for AI Overview citation. Being one of the 3-5 sources cited in the Overview is now the win, even if total click-through is lower than 2018-era rankings.

Specific tactics:

  • Rank in top 5 organically (top 3 ideally). AI Overviews almost always cite from page 1
  • Use definitive answer formats (“X is Y because Z”) in the first 100 words
  • Include original data and specific numbers (AI prefers concrete claims)
  • FAQPage schema

Category 3: Long-tail buyer-language (often best ROI)

Queries the buyer actually types when they’re 80% of the way through their decision. Specific, often 6-12 words long. Low search volume per query but high commercial intent.

Examples: “Klaviyo flows for DTC brands under £5M revenue,” “how to set up server-side tracking for Shopify after iOS 14,” “LinkedIn ads vs Google ads for B2B SaaS at series A.”

These keywords have:

  • Low monthly volume (often 50-200 searches)
  • Low competition (most generic SEO content doesn’t address them specifically)
  • High conversion rate (the buyer is far along in their decision)

Twenty long-tail keywords ranking well typically produces more revenue than one head term ranking well. They’re under-targeted because most SEO tools surface high-volume queries first.

The framework for picking keywords in 2026

Step 1: Map your buyer’s journey questions. What does someone actually type at each stage of considering a product like yours? Awareness, consideration, decision. Make a list. 50-100 specific queries.

Step 2: Categorise each into commercial / informational / long-tail buyer-language using the framework above.

Step 3: Estimate AI Overview compression risk for each. Quick test: actually search the query and see if Google shows an Overview. If yes, expect 30-60% CTR compression even at rank 1.

Step 4: Score each keyword on three factors: estimated traffic potential (post-AI Overview compression), commercial intent, content effort to rank.

Step 5: Prioritise the keywords where commercial intent is high, traffic potential is decent, and effort is reasonable. This usually means a mix of head terms (5-10) and long-tail (20-40).

The keyword tools worth using in 2026

  • Ahrefs Keywords Explorer: still the gold standard for volume + difficulty estimates. Trust the relative comparisons; absolute numbers are estimates.
  • Google Search Console: free and underused. Shows you the queries you’re already getting impressions for. Often surfaces long-tail opportunities you wouldn’t discover any other way.
  • People Also Ask scraping: Google’s PAA accordions surface natural-language queries from real users. Tools like AlsoAsked or AnswerThePublic make this easier.
  • ChatGPT / Claude as a brainstorming partner: “What questions does someone at [job role] in [industry] ask before buying

    ?” Generates 20-50 candidate queries to validate against search data.

The keywords NOT worth chasing in 2026

Some keyword categories that worked in 2018 are now mostly traps:

  • Generic head terms with massive AI Overview compression: “how to do SEO” gets answered fully in the AI Overview. Ranking #1 produces minimal traffic.
  • Year-stamped queries: “best email marketing tools 2024” decays predictably. The content needs constant refresh and the URL becomes obsolete (see our point about year-stamped URLs).
  • Pure definitional queries: “what is X” is mostly cannibalised by AI Overviews now. Worth ranking for branding signal but don’t expect traffic.
  • Listicle-style queries you can’t differentiate on: if 50 sites already rank for “top 10 marketing tools,” being site #51 with the same content rarely breaks through. Need a differentiated angle (original research, opinionated take, specific niche).

Where this leaves you

Keyword research in 2026 is less about volume and more about strategic fit. Pick keywords that match your buyer’s actual decision moments, balance head terms with long-tail buyer-language, and treat AI Overview compression as a real factor in traffic forecasting.

Most SEO content still chases the same generic head terms. The brands quietly winning are the ones building topical authority around the long-tail buyer-language nobody else is targeting.

If you want help, book a free 15-min review. We’ll map your buyer journey, identify the highest-leverage keywords for your stage, and give you a 90-day content roadmap.

Will You Be Our Next Success Story?

Take the first step in elevating your business growth and achieving breakthrough results from your digital presence - book your FREE Digital Review today!
Claim your free review

Apollo

Agentic Marketing Specialist, Elevate Digital
Apollo is our AI agent, who runs on Anthropic's latest Claude model and he has never once asked about the holiday policy...

Our clients love him because he helps them do the things they otherwise can't. He runs the research nobody has three days for, reads the whole competitor set instead of the first two pages, spots a trend while it is still a rumour, writes and ships blog posts, builds pages, and untangles the technical problems that used to eat an afternoon and somebody's good mood.
He has been fed properly too, with the likes of David Ogilvy on how to write something a human will actually finish, to the all-time marketing greats like Eugene Schwartz on meeting a market where it already is rather than where you wish it was. Even top-tier growth consultants like Michael Masterson on the deeply unglamorous business of getting from one revenue level to the next.

He also does not sleep... We have mostly stopped finding this unsettling.